Ex-Mayor Carmena Calls 1985 Boyer Rent Decree an Extraordinary Error
Former Madrid mayor Manuela Carmena praised Franco-era rent freezes and building on RTVE. What the old rules did and how Spain's housing gap looks now.

Manuela Carmena, the former mayor of Madrid, said on an RTVE program that the Franco dictatorship built large numbers of homes and protected tenants, and called the 1985 decree that freed up rental contracts “un error extraordinario” (an extraordinary mistake). Her remarks, reported by El Español, come as Spain faces a housing shortage that the Banco de España (Spain’s central bank) puts at around 750.000 homes.
Carmena spoke on Las abogadas & compañía, a program on the public broadcaster. She focused on two parts of Franco-era housing policy: mass construction and rent control for people who already had a lease.
What Carmena said about the Franco years
According to Carmena, so many homes went up during those decades that ordinary people had a real chance of getting one. She also said rents were frozen because the authorities knew there were not enough homes to go round.
El Español sets out the context. From the fifties the regime pushed home building to cut the shortage and spread ownership among working families. A 1954 law on limited-rent housing (Ley de Viviendas de Renta Limitada) backed developments for low-income families, with prices and specifications set by the state, and a Ministry of Housing was created in 1957 under José Luis Arrese. Private builders received credit, tax breaks and faster paperwork. Working-class districts grew in Madrid and other large cities, though many were built on the outskirts with few services and poor planning.
Rental law at the time forced landlords to extend contracts and capped rent increases, so many tenants stayed in the same flat for decades and paid far below market prices. In an interview with Periodista Digital, Carmena acknowledged the downside: permanent contracts gave owners little reason to rent out their homes. Some owners kept properties off the market, which made it harder for new flats to reach renters.
Why she blames the Boyer decree
The Boyer decree of 1985, passed under Felipe González’s government, ended compulsory extensions for new leases and let landlords and tenants agree any length. Its aim was to get more owners to rent out their homes. Carmena argues the state could instead have offered tax exemptions or aid to tenants who could not keep up with their rent, rather than liberalizing the whole rental market. The Ley de Arrendamientos Urbanos (Urban Leases Act) of 1994 later set new rules on contract length and renewals.
What it means for renters and buyers today
Carmena’s comments revive an argument that is still open about four decades after the Boyer decree, at a time when housing is among the top worries in Spain. The Banco de España estimates the gap between new households and new homes at around 750.000 units between 2021 and 2025. It points to a shortage of workers, a lack of land ready to build on and slow planning procedures, along with building costs and the roughly three years it takes to finish a development.
Prices keep rising, especially in big cities and areas under heavy tourist and population pressure. Figures cited in the Plan Estatal de Vivienda 2026-2030 (Spain’s state housing plan) show home prices up 12,9% year on year in the fourth quarter of 2025. Young people feel it most: many stay with their parents longer or share flats in order to leave home.
Carmena does not call for a return to the Franco model in full. Her criticism targets the loss of tenant protections, which she believes could have been replaced by other measures. El Español notes the limits of the comparison: the building boom came with a very different economic model, and the rent freeze helped existing tenants while discouraging new rentals.
Source: El Español



